CASE and Takeuchi are two brands that consistently stand out in the construction and landscaping industries in terms of compact excavators.
At Luby Equipment Services, we’re proud to offer both of these top-tier manufacturers in our lineup. But how do they compare, and which might suit your needs? Let’s compare some of their popular compact excavator models.
Brand Overview
Before we get into specific models, let’s briefly look at what each brand brings to the table:
- CASE Construction Equipment: With a legacy dating back to 1842, CASE has long been a leader in construction equipment. It is known for its rugged reliability and innovative features.
- Takeuchi: Founded in 1963, Takeuchi is credited with introducing the world’s first compact excavator. They’ve built a strong reputation for compact equipment that delivers excellent performance and comfort.
Popular Models Comparison
Let’s compare some popular models from each manufacturer:
CASE CX37C vs. Takeuchi TB235-2
- Operating Weight:
- CASE CX37C: 8,350 lbs (3,787 kg)
- Takeuchi TB235-2: 7,760 lbs (3,520 kg)
- Dig Depth:
- CASE CX37C: 11’9″ (3.58 m)
- Takeuchi TB235-2: 11’9″ (3.58 m)
- Engine Power:
- CASE CX37C: 24.4 hp (18.2 kW)
- Takeuchi TB235-2: 24.4 hp (18.2 kW)
- Bucket Breakout Force:
- CASE CX37C: 6,900 lbf (30.7 kN)
- Takeuchi TB235-2: 9,127 lbf (40.6 kN)
This comparison shows that while the CASE model is slightly heavier, both machines offer identical dig depths and engine power. The Takeuchi model, however, provides significantly more bucket breakout force, which could be advantageous for more demanding digging conditions.
CASE CX60C vs. Takeuchi TB260
- Operating Weight:
- CASE CX60C: 13,300 lbs (6,033 kg)
- Takeuchi TB260: 12,125 lbs (5,500 kg)
- Dig Depth:
- CASE CX60C: 13’3″ (4.04 m)
- Takeuchi TB260: 12’9″ (3.89 m)
- Engine Power:
- CASE CX60C: 64.7 hp (48.3 kW)
- Takeuchi TB260: 47.6 hp (35.5 kW)
- Bucket Breakout Force:
- CASE CX60C: 9,550 lbf (42.5 kN)
- Takeuchi TB260: 12,756 lbf (56.7 kN)
We see more significant differences in this larger class. The CASE model offers more weight, dig depth, and engine power, potentially providing stability and overall performance. However, the Takeuchi again leads in bucket breakout force, maintaining its edge in challenging digging scenarios.
Key Considerations
When choosing between CASE and Takeuchi compact excavators, consider these factors:
- Comfort and Ergonomics: Both brands prioritize operator comfort, but personal preference plays a role. CASE often receives praise for its intuitive controls, while Takeuchi is known for spacious cabs.
- Serviceability: CASE machines typically feature ground-level access points for daily maintenance, while Takeuchi is noted for their durable components that can reduce long-term maintenance needs.
- Attachments and Versatility: Both manufacturers offer a wide range of attachments. CASE’s hydraulic quick coupler system is highly regarded, while Takeuchi’s auxiliary hydraulic systems are known for their smooth operation.
- Fuel Efficiency: Takeuchi often edges out the competition in fuel efficiency, leading to significant savings over time, especially for high-usage operations.
- Technology Integration: CASE has been pushing forward, offering options like its SiteWatch telematics system on many models. While Takeuchi also incorporates modern tech, it tends to focus more on perfecting its core mechanical systems.
Making Your Decision
Choosing between CASE and Takeuchi often depends on specific job requirements and personal preferences. Here are some general guidelines:
- CASE might be your best bet if you prioritize raw power and cutting-edge technology integration.
- Takeuchi could be the way to go if you’re looking for fuel efficiency and exceptional breakout force.
Remember, the best excavator for you depends on your unique needs. Factors like your typical job sites, the materials you’ll be excavating, your budget, and your operators’ preferences should all play into your decision.
Which is better, CASE or Takeuchi compact excavators?
CASE and Takeuchi compact excavators are both excellent choices, depending on your needs. CASE offers durability and advanced hydraulics, while Takeuchi excels in compact designs and operator comfort. Contact Luby Equipment to find the right fit for your project.
What are the key differences between CAE CX60C and Takeuchi TB260?
The CASE CX60C offers a larger cab and superior hydraulic performance, making it ideal for heavy-duty jobs. The Takeuchi TB260 features a compact design and ease of maintenance, perfect for smaller job sites and landscaping.
What is the best compact excavator for landscaping?
For landscaping, the Takeuchi TB260 stands out for its compact size and versatility, while the CASE CX37C offers excellent maneuverability and power for tight spaces. Visit Luby Equipment to compare models.
Do CASE and Takeuchi offer attachments for compact excavators?
Yes, CASE and Takeuchi offer many attachments, including buckets, hydraulic thumbs, and augers. Luby Equipment can help you choose the right attachments for your specific needs.
Where can I buy or rent CASE or Takeuchi compact excavators?
Luby Equipment offers both sales and rentals of CASE and Takeuchi compact excavators. Visit one of our locations in Missouri or Illinois to explore our inventory.
Contact Us Today
At Luby Equipment Services, we’re here to help you navigate these choices. Our team of experts can provide detailed insights into each model, arrange demonstrations, and help you find the perfect compact excavator for your needs. Whether you choose CASE, Takeuchi, or another brand from our diverse inventory, we’re committed to supporting you with top-notch sales, rental, and service support.